By Carey Gillam
The World Health Organization is set to examine a widely used pesticide and agribusiness is bracing for bad news, less than 3 months after the group classified another popular herbicide as "probably" cancer-causing.
Twenty-four scientists representing WHO's International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) are set to analyze scientific findings regarding links between cancer in humans and the herbicide known as 2,4-D at a June 2-9 meeting in Lyon, France.
A separate group of IARC scientists in March unanimously decided to classify glyphosate, the key ingredient in Monsanto Co.’s Roundup weedkiller, as "probably carcinogenic to humans." The designation prompted outrage and calls for a retraction from Monsanto, and demands by some public officials and consumers for bans on the pesticide.
Many believe the same could happen for 2,4-D.
"I do think they are going to upgrade 2,4-D," said Michael Hansen, a senior scientist at Consumers Union who has served on an advisory committee of the USDA as well as a WHO consultation project.
"There is just as strong, or even a stronger case (for links to cancer), on 2,4-D than there was for glyphosate," he said.
IARC's work is of particular concern to Dow AgroSciences, a unit of Dow Chemical Co. The company manufactures 2,4-D and this year is rolling out a product that combines 2,4-D with glyphosate after gaining approval from the EPA last year.
Dow will have representatives at the meeting, and a 2,4-D task force backed by Dow funded an analysis of 14 studies that refutes concerns about 2,4-D and cancer that has been submitted to IARC.
"The epidemiology evidence does not support an association between 2,4-D and NHL (non-Hodgkin lymphoma), gastric cancer, or prostate cancer risk," said Julie Goodman, a scientist and consultant working for the 2,4-D task force.
However, a different analysis of scientific studies did find cancer connections with 2,4-D, said IARC scientist Maria Leon, who co-authored the analysis last year.
There were indications that farm exposure to 2,4-D was associated with a 40% higher risk of NHL. Determining the strength of the evidence will be up to the IARC working group, Leon said.
Maarten Bosland, a U.S. cancer scientist and member of the IARC group evaluating 2,4-D, said he knows the work will be closely watched and that the outcome will rely on the scientific evidence.
"There is nothing that anybody can say at this point. We haven't seen all the evidence," Bosland said.
Like glyphosate, 2,4-D (2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid) is a long-used, popular herbicide. Homeowners as well as farmers and ranchers use products containing 2,4-D.
Critics for years have said 2,4-D has very clear ties to several types of cancer and note that it was a key ingredient in Agent Orange, which was used to defoliate jungles in the Vietnam War. But agribusiness interests, U.S. regulators and others say evidence of cancer connections is lacking.
A coalition of U.S. farmer and environmental groups have sued the EPA, seeking to overturn approval for Dow's new herbicide.